Trending Now
---Advertisement---

SC to consider on Jan 11 whether to close case on regulation of private varsities

Summarize with AI

---Advertisement---

New Delhi, Nov 19 The Supreme Court on Thursday said it will decide on January 11 the fate of a petition whose scope was widened to nationwide proceedings over regulation of private universities by a bench led by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah.

The petition filed by a student, Ayesha Jain, under Article 32 seeking direction to Amity University to update her name in its official records after she legally changed it, was recently withdrawn by CJI Surya Kant from the bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah and earmarked to a new bench of Justice Vikram Nath.

Taking note of expanding the scope of the original dispute between a student and a private university to a nationwide examination of the regulation and functioning of private universities, the CJI made it clear at a full court meeting held last month that judges cannot assume jurisdiction over subjects not assigned to them and emphasised strict adherence to the PIL roster.

The new bench headed by Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh said that since it got the case files late at night, it will consider on January 11 whether to continue examining the larger issue or to close the matter.

It said the court would look into the grievances raised by the student against Amity University and consider what relief, if any, could be granted to her.

Justice Nath said that the court would thereafter examine the scope of the wider PIL proceedings and decide whether they should continue or be closed.

“What we propose is, we will fix this matter in January and we will consider the grievance of the petitioner as to what relief can be granted to her and whether or not to grant any relief. Whatever will be the case.

“The university has already filed a counter affidavit. At that stage, we will consider what is the scope of the PIL and whether or not to continue further with that or to close everything,” Justice Nath said.

The bench granted court-appointed investigator, retired IPS officer Ashok Prasad, time until the end of December to complete his enquiry concerning the university’s conduct and submit a final report.

“Whatever report you have prepared, file it by December 31, we will examine it,” it said.

Prasad was appointed by a bench headed by Justice Amanullah.

Additional Solicitor General K M Nataraj contended that according to previous orders, all states have been called upon to submit reports on the functioning of private universities.

He said that the volume of material being furnished was substantial and each state was submitting approximately 40,000 to 60,000-page reports, making the exercise challenging and unmanageable.

The bench, while directing the registry to list the matter on January 11, clarified that parties are at liberty to mention the matter for an earlier hearing if required.

During the hearing, Jain raised grievances concerning the lawyers who had previously represented her and said they allegedly colluded with the university and withheld the reports filed by the institution.

Justice Nath said that the court could not adjudicate grievances against lawyers and advised her to approach the Bar Council with a complaint.

When she sought appointment of a new counsel to represent her, Justice Nath indicated that the court would consider appointing someone to assist her.

Senior advocate Ajit Sinha, appearing for Amity University, said that the grievances raised by Jain have been addressed and sought closure of the proceedings qua the varsity.

Jain had approached the top court by filing a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution as Amity University refused to update her name in its official records after she legally changed it from Khushi Jain.

She alleged that the university’s refusal and the conduct of its officials resulted in her inability to meet the attendance requirements for examinations, causing her to lose an academic year.

The university subsequently refunded her fees and paid her Rs 1 lakh as compensation. The bench of Justices Amanullah and N V Anjaria expressed dissatisfaction with its conduct.

On November 20, 2025, the court expanded the proceedings into a nationwide examination of the establishment, functioning, funding and regulatory oversight of private and deemed universities.

The bench had sought information from the Centre, states and Union Territories regarding the statutory framework governing these institutions, the concessions and benefits granted to them, land allotments, admission policies, faculty recruitment and grievance redressal mechanisms.

In February 2026, Justice Amanullah-led bench appointed R M Sharma, former additional secretary to the Ministry of Law & Justice, to examine broader regulatory issues, while Ashok Prasad was appointed to conduct a preliminary enquiry into matters concerning petitioner’s grievance against Amity University.

In September, the court directed private universities to disclose their audited financial statements for the preceding five years, including details of funds generated, their utilisation and payments made to individuals not directly involved in educational activities.

It had observed that private universities cannot be permitted to operate as profit-making institutions and the proceedings were subsequently expanded to address alleged irregularities in educational institutions, including a purported fake medical college operating from a dilapidated farmhouse in Uttar Pradesh’s Etah district.

(PTI News)

Join WhatsApp

Join Now
---Advertisement---

Leave a Comment