Lucknow, Nov 18 The Allahabad High Court has ruled that coconuts cannot be sold in fruit and vegetable markets as they are classified as an oilseed under the applicable agricultural produce classification.
A division bench of Justice Alok Mathur and Justice Amitabh Kumar Rai passed the order on November 12 while dismissing a petition filed by Ghaziabad-based M/s Three Star Fruit Company.
The firm had sought permission to sell green coconuts at the New Fruit and Vegetable Market in Sahibabad and challenged the classification of coconut as an oilseed under the Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1964.
The petitioner argued that coconut is botanically a fruit and should therefore be allowed to be sold in the fruit and vegetable market. It also claimed that it had been engaged in the business at the market since 2003 and was earlier permitted to sell coconuts.
Opposing the petition, the state government submitted that coconut was classified as an agricultural oilseed through an amendment dated January 30, 1995. It said coconuts could instead be sold at the foodgrain market in Govindpuram, Ghaziabad, after payment of prescribed charges.
Upholding the government’s position, the bench observed that a commodity’s classification was determined not only by its botanical identity but also by its commercial use and market identity.
The court noted that coconut exists in different forms, including green, tender and mature coconut, besides dried coconut. While green coconut may be consumed as a fruit, dried coconut is used for extracting oil.
“Merely because green coconut is consumed as a fruit, the entire category cannot be treated as fruit for commercial purposes,” the bench observed.
It also said that previous inaction by authorities or their failure to prohibit coconut trading in the market could not create a legal right for the trader to continue the practice.
Holding the 1995 classification valid, the court dismissed the petition.
(PTI News)





