New Delhi, Nov 17 In a relief to Azam Khan, the Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed an appeal by the Uttar Pradesh government challenging an Allahabad High Court decision to stay the Samajwadi Party leader’s conviction in a fake birth certificate case.
A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu also allowed the appeals filed by the SP leader’s wife Tazeen Fatma and son Abdullah Azam Khan against the denial of similar relief.
“The ultimate exercise of discretion in staying Mohammad Azam Khan’s conviction does not suffer from any manifest perversity, and we find no compelling ground to interfere under Article 136 of the Constitution. The criminal appeal of the State, thus, has to fail,” it said.
The apex court refused to agree with the Uttar Pradesh government’s submission that the high court did assign reasons for the grant of suspension of sentence in Khan’s case.
“The role of Azam Khan and the evidence on record regarding his complicity in the crime appear to have been discussed by the high court in the impugned judgment.
“The high court, taking into consideration the substantial period of custody already undergone by Azam Khan, the advanced stage of his life, and the absence of direct evidence proving that he personally executed the forged signatures on the municipal registers, exercised its discretion to suspend his sentence,” the bench said.
The court said although the high court did not record extensive reasons for staying Khan’s conviction, the reasons which weighed with the high court for granting a stay of suspension of sentence imposed on him do constitute valid grounds for granting a stay of conviction.
The top court also questioned the high court’s refusal to grant identical interim relief to Abdullah Azam Khan and Fatma, terming it a violation of the doctrine of parity and a patent error of jurisdiction.
“The entire prosecution matrix rests upon a single, unified charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B of the IPC, tied to the same documentary evidence, namely, the two conflicting birth certificates issued at Rampur and Lucknow.
“No distinct overt act of manual forgery is individually attributed to Abdullah Azam Khan or Dr Tazeen Fatma beyond their joint status as co-conspirators and alleged beneficiaries.
“Where the evidentiary foundation, the statutory offences, and the conspiracy matrix bind all three of the family to an identical legal fate, according favourable treatment to the patriarch while denying a stay of conviction to his son and wife (who also happens to be a septuagenarian) constitutes an arbitrary differentiation,” the bench said.
According to the prosecution, the case dates back to January 3, 2019, when Akash Saxena, who is now the BJP MLA from Rampur, lodged a complaint alleging that Azam Khan (78) and his wife got two birth certificates made for their son Abdullah Azam Khan.
Subsequently, the Rampur sessions court found the trio guilty under IPC sections 420 (cheating), 467 (forgery of valuable security), 468 (forgery for cheating), 471 (using forged documents), 472 (possessing counterfeit seal), and 120 (B) (criminal conspiracy), and awarded seven years’ imprisonment to each.
(PTI News)





