Trending Now
---Advertisement---

Mother cannot be denied child’s custody citing inadequate financial resources: HC

Summarize with AI

---Advertisement---

Prayagraj, Nov 16 The Allahabad High Court has held that a mother cannot be deprived of the custody of her child based on the presumption that her financial means are inadequate, dismissing an appeal filed by the grandparents seeking the child’s custody.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra said the grandparents’ better financial resources by themselves cannot be a ground for depriving the mother of the child’s custody.

The bench dismissed the appeal, stating that the grandparents could provide financial assistance for the child’s upbringing rather than seek custody on grounds of their superior financial position.

“The mere fact that the appellants may be having better financial resources in comparison to the mother, the same in itself cannot be a ground for depriving the mother of custody of her minor son,” the court observed.

The appeal was filed by the child’s paternal grandparents challenging a single-judge order passed on May 27 in a habeas corpus petition filed by the mother.

The mother had approached the high court alleging that after her husband’s death, her in-laws had forcibly detained their minor son. She had approached police authorities, but, having received no relief, filed the habeas corpus petition seeking custody of the child.

The single judge, after considering the affidavits filed by both sides regarding their income, assets and proposed arrangements for the child’s welfare, directed that custody be handed over to the mother.

Challenging the order, the grandparents contended in their special appeal that the child’s welfare lay with them and not the mother, as she had no sufficient source of income to maintain him.

They argued that the single judge had handed over custody merely on the ground that she was the child’s mother. They also questioned the denial of visitation rights to them.

In its judgment dated October 27, the division bench said the single judge had considered all aspects, including the child’s tender age, continuity of care with the mother, emotional bonding and daily care, as well as the mother’s role in shaping his moral values, discipline and emotional security.

The division bench noted that the couple’s younger daughter, aged about four years, remains with the mother, while it was the son who had been kept by the grandparents since the day of his father’s cremation.

Regarding the issue of visitation rights, the court observed that the grandparents were free to seek appropriate remedies before the district court and could also institute fresh proceedings in relation to the child.

(PTI News)

Join WhatsApp

Join Now
---Advertisement---

Leave a Comment