New Delhi, Nov 20 Former chief election commissioner S Y Quraishi on Friday said the framers of the Constitution may not have anticipated a situation such as the one involving present CEC Gyanesh Kumar, while stressing that independent constitutional institutions cannot depend solely on the integrity of individuals and need strong institutional safeguards.
Delivering the V M Tarkunde Memorial Lecture here, Quraishi said, “Great elections do not mean great democracy.” He subsequently summed up India’s situation by saying, “So, great elections, bad democracy — that has been our unfortunate situation.”
Quraishi called for an independent audit of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, raising concerns over alleged wrongful deletions, procedural lapses and the exclusion of eligible voters. He said accuracy and inclusion are both constitutional responsibilities and should not be treated as competing objectives.
“Probably, they did not anticipate a Gyanesh Kumar someday,” he said while recalling the decision of the Constitution’s founding fathers to give every adult Indian the right to vote, irrespective of education or economic status.
Questioning the functioning of the Election Commission (EC), the former CEC alleged that decisions are being taken unilaterally despite the statutory requirement for collective decision-making. Referring to reports that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had raised objections on at least 14 occasions to decisions taken without their knowledge or approval, he said the EC is not synonymous with the CEC.
He also questioned the reported centralisation of electoral roll management through the ECINET portal and app, alleging that it has undermined the statutory authority of electoral registration officers (EROs). Technology, he said, must serve the law and cannot override the powers vested in statutory authorities.
Referring to the SIR exercise in West Bengal, Quraishi said the names of more than 27 lakh voters were deleted during adjudication, while around 22 lakh had appealed against their exclusion. However, only 1,607 names were restored before the Assembly election.
He cited subsequent appellate tribunal decisions, in which about 93 per cent of the cases decided were found to involve wrongful exclusion, arguing that the scale of the issue warrants serious scrutiny.
Quraishi said elections alone do not guarantee a healthy democracy, stressing that a poll victory does not confer the ownership of the State and that parliamentary majorities do not dilute the obligation to respect constitutional limits. He said independent institutions are particularly important when governments enjoy overwhelming majorities and recalled that the EC’s credibility has historically rested on regulating the ruling party, while reassuring the opposition.
(PTI News)




