Prayagraj, Nov 19 The Allahabad High Court on Thursday barred litigants from carrying phones inside courtrooms and ordered the custody of a Varanasi resident who was found recording proceedings inside court no. 55 without permission.
Justice Vikram D Chauhan passed the order while hearing a petition filed by one Kuldeep Batra against the State of Uttar Pradesh.
During court proceedings, Additional Government Advocate P K Singh informed the court that a man was recording the court proceedings on his phone. Upon questioning, the man identified himself as Raj Kulshrestha, a resident of Habibpura in Varanasi, and admitted to recording the proceedings without permission.
However, he could not state a reason for his act. The bench secretary took custody of the phone and found three videos of the proceedings on the device.
Kulshrestha had no case before the bench. He produced a pass from the Registry that allowed entry only to the advocates’ chamber and not to the courtroom.
He told the court that advocate Bhanu Pratap Seth, junior to the petitioner’s counsel Nitish Kumar Soni, had brought him to the court. Neither Soni, who was out of station, nor Seth was in court during the hearing.
Batra was also in the courtroom with a pass for the advocates’ chamber. Batra said that he did not know Kulshrestha.
Justice Chauhan noted that the court hears matters involving liberty, child abuse, Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Enforcement Directorate (ED) and MPs and MLAs, and facts from such cases cannot go on networks without court determination.
The court said, “The principle of open justice means proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, the same does not amount to ‘free broadcast’ by any unauthorized individual.”
Holding that the presiding officer of each court regulates broadcast and no one can record proceedings without leave, the bench ordered, “In view of the situation prevailing in the court and concerning the security of the court, the litigants shall not be permitted to enter into the court rooms along with mobile phones. If the mobile phone is found with any of the litigants in the court room, then the concerned advocate is solely responsible for the same.”
The bench directed the registrar general to paste a notice at the pass counter and instructed the registrar (protocol) to stop litigants without passes from entering courtrooms, print the phone ban on passes and submit a report.
The court officer was ordered to hand over Kulshrestha to the chief judicial magistrate (CJM), Prayagraj, for examination and custody with a direction to grant him bail on bonds and two sureties on the condition that he appears before the court at 10 am on Friday.
The court also ordered the court officer to keep Kulshrestha’s phone in a cover and produce it on Friday.
Advocates Soni and Seth, along with Kulshrestha, were directed to explain why proceedings for interference in the administration of justice should not start against them, while Batra must file an affidavit explaining his entry into the courtroom.
Additional Advocate General Manish Goyal was also requested to appear in court on Friday.
(PTI News)





