New Delhi, Nov 18 The Central Information Commission (CIC) has directed the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) to provide an RTI applicant general findings of its internal assessments on cartelisation, market concentration and creation of entry barriers, after the platform acknowledged analysing repeated allocation of orders to the same sellers but refused to disclose related reports.
GeM, launched by the Centre on August 9, 2016, is an online platform for the procurement of goods and services by government ministries, departments, public sector undertakings and other government organisations.
The RTI applicant had also asked about a purported “link facility” through which procurement or bid links were allegedly sent to selected sellers. GeM, however, denied the existence of any such facility on its portal.
In an order, Information Commissioner Khushwant Singh Sethi directed GeM to provide the general findings emerging from its reports, reviews or risk assessments concerning cartelisation, market concentration and creation of entry barriers, if any, maintained by it.
The applicant, Goutam Mohanta, had specifically sought copies of reports, reviews or risk assessments maintained by GeM concerning cartelisation, concentration of procurement orders among sellers and creation of entry barriers.
The CIC directed the platform to “provide a specific and point-wise reply” indicating the findings emerging from these reports, reviews or risk assessments, if any.
The direction came after GeM, in response to another part of the RTI application, acknowledged that it conducts internal analysis regarding repeated allocation of orders to the same sellers or groups of sellers.
However, it refused to disclose the related reports, claiming that the information was commercially confidential and market-sensitive.
GeM invoked Section 8(1)(d) of the RTI Act, 2005, to deny the information, stating that its disclosure was likely to adversely affect the competitive position of sellers.
The commission observed that the exemption had been claimed in a general and mechanical manner without demonstrating how disclosure of the specific information would adversely affect the competitive position of any third party.
“The mere description of information as commercially confidential or market-sensitive, without establishing the applicability of the statutory exemption, is not sufficient to deny access under the RTI Act,” the commission said.
The applicant had also sought details about the introduction of a purported “link facility”, including its policy objectives, beneficiaries, monitoring mechanism and audit trail, alleging that procurement links were being sent to selected sellers.
GeM said the query was not clear and informed the applicant that “there is no such link facility on the GeM portal”.
It consequently did not provide responses to subsequent questions on whether such a facility could result in certain sellers repeatedly receiving opportunities to participate in similar bids.
In response to another query, GeM informed the applicant that 3,36,904 unique sellers had received orders on the platform till date. However, it said it did not maintain data on the number of unique sellers participating or the percentage of transactions concentrated among a limited number of repeated sellers, as the data was dynamic in nature.
On measures to prevent cartelisation, GeM said it examines complaints received through official channels and acts against firms involved in cartelisation in accordance with its General Terms and Conditions and Incident Management Policy.
“Buyers are also enabled to view network-related details of participating bidders to identify cartelisation and take appropriate action,” GeM said.
The platform also said it provides system-enabled filters for MSME, women entrepreneurs and SC/ST seller categories to promote inclusive participation.
The commission also examined the applicant’s request for year-wise procurement figures through GeM by the Indian Army, BSF, SSB, CRPF and other paramilitary forces.
GeM had initially invoked Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act, relating to information held in a fiduciary capacity, to deny the figures. During the hearing, its representatives claimed exemption under Section 8(1)(a).
The commission observed that GeM had not adequately explained the justification for the exemption and directed it to furnish a revised and categorical reply, identifying the relevant exemption clause and providing cogent reasons if any information was withheld.
According to figures furnished in the RTI reply, GeM recorded government procurement orders worth Rs 5.42 lakh crore in 2024-25. The second appeal was disposed of with these directions.
(PTI News)





