Kolkata, Nov 17 The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday upheld the death sentence of a convict in the rape and murder of a five-year-old girl in West Bengal’s Hooghly district in 2024.
The high court, according to special public prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee, has upheld a death sentence in a case in Bengal after a gap of 34 years.
The last such instance was in 1992, when the court had upheld the death sentence of Dhananjoy Chatterjee in the Hetal Parekh murder case, he said.
In the more than three decades since then, several trial courts have awarded death sentences in different cases, but none survived judicial scrutiny of the high court.
A special POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences) Act court in Hooghly district had, on January 17, 2025, convicted 50-year-old Ashok Singh of rape and murder of the girl and awarded him the death sentence.
Singh had challenged the conviction and sentence before the high court.
The state government also moved the high court seeking mandatory confirmation of the death sentence.
A division bench, comprising Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray, heard the matter for over a year and upheld the conviction and death sentence of Singh.
The incident dates back to November 24, 2024, when a five-year-old girl mysteriously went missing from the Gurap area of Hooghly district.
A search was launched by her family members, following which the blood-soaked body of the child, bearing multiple injuries, was found concealed under a pile of dry firewood inside the convict’s house. The gruesome incident had sparked widespread outrage in the area.
“The hearing in the case had been completed during the tenure of the previous government, and the matter was awaiting delivery of the verdict. During this period, several cases involving horrific and brutal crimes, in which young children were raped and murdered, came to the attention of the present Chief Minister, Suvendu Adhikari. He personally began monitoring these cases and appointed me as special counsel representing the state government in this particular case,” Chatterjee said.
“The objective was to ensure that the accused received exemplary punishment and that a strong message was sent to society,” the counsel added.
Appearing before the division bench, Chatterjee submitted that in his many years of practising law, he had never come across a case involving such a brutal and heinous rape and murder of a five-year-old.
During the tenure of the previous TMC government, trial courts awarded death sentences in 45 cases, but none was carried out, officials said.
Several convicts were subsequently acquitted or had their sentences commuted by the Calcutta High Court, they added.
Since the execution of Dhananjoy Chatterjee on August 14, 2004, West Bengal has not witnessed another execution. No case has so far reached the Supreme Court after the high court upheld a death sentence.
Even in high-profile cases such as the gruesome rape and murder of a college student in Kamduni in North 24 Parganas district, the high court overturned the death sentences awarded by the trial court.
Legal experts attributed this trend primarily to the twin factors of lapses in police investigations and inadequate presentation of arguments and evidence during court proceedings.
(PTI News)





